The Bone Wars: A Tale of Dinosaurs, Discovery, and Destruction
- Adam Wood
- Jul 17
- 5 min read
Imagine a world where two brilliant scientists, driven by ambition and ego, race against each other across the untamed American West, unearthing the remains of creatures that walked the Earth millions of years ago. Their goal? To outdo each other by discovering and naming as many dinosaurs as possible. What sounds like the plot of an action-adventure novel is, in fact, a true story. Welcome to the Bone Wars, one of the most fascinating and contentious chapters in the history of science.
The Bone Wars, also known as the Great Dinosaur Rush, was a heated and often underhanded rivalry between two 19th-century palaeontologists: Edward Drinker Cope and Othniel Charles Marsh. Their feud, which spanned more than two decades, fuelled a frenzy of fossil hunting across North America and led to the discovery of over 130 new dinosaur species. But it also left a legacy of destroyed fossils, scientific errors, and personal ruin.
Meet the Rivals
Edward Drinker Cope was a self-taught naturalist from Philadelphia, born into a wealthy Quaker family in 1840. Brilliant and passionate, Cope was publishing scientific papers in his teens and quickly earned a reputation as a prodigy in natural sciences. He had a keen eye for anatomy and an insatiable curiosity for prehistoric life.
Othniel Charles Marsh, born in 1831 in upstate New York, came from more modest beginnings but had the good fortune of a wealthy uncle, George Peabody, who funded his education at Yale and later helped establish the Peabody Museum of Natural History. Marsh was meticulous, calculating, and methodical—a stark contrast to Cope’s impulsive and prolific nature.
Initially, the two men were cordial. They even went on fossil-hunting trips together in the late 1860s. But their friendship soured quickly, possibly due to Marsh’s public humiliation of Cope over a reconstruction error involving the marine reptile Elasmosaurus. Cope had mistakenly placed the skull on the tail end of the skeleton, and Marsh made sure the scientific community knew about it. The incident ignited a bitter rivalry that would shape the field of palaeontology for decades to come.
The Race for Fossils
During the late 19th century, the American West was a treasure trove of prehistoric remains. Vast, unexplored territories in Colorado, Wyoming, Nebraska, and Montana held fossil-rich rock formations that would become the battlegrounds for the Bone Wars.
Both Cope and Marsh established networks of field collectors and fossil hunters. They hired scouts, bribed railroad workers, and even recruited schoolboys to bring them bones. Their methods were aggressive and sometimes illegal. The two men would often hear about a promising dig site and rush to outbid or sabotage the other.
In one instance, Marsh allegedly sent his team to a site in Como Bluff, Wyoming, where Cope's workers were excavating. His men reportedly destroyed fossils and tampered with the site to prevent Cope from making any discoveries. Cope retaliated in kind, and such tactics became common. Spies, theft, and deliberate misinformation were all part of the game.
Scientific Achievements Amid Chaos
Despite the chaos and unethical behaviour, the Bone Wars produced an extraordinary body of work. Between them, Cope and Marsh named over 130 dinosaur species, many of which are still recognised today. Among the most iconic discoveries:
Stegosaurus (Marsh): Known for its distinctive back plates and tail spikes.
Triceratops (Marsh): A three-horned herbivore that became one of the most recognisable dinosaurs.
Diplodocus (Marsh): One of the longest dinosaurs ever discovered.
Apatosaurus/Brontosaurus (Marsh): A case that later became a taxonomic controversy.
Allosaurus (Marsh): A formidable predator from the Late Jurassic.
Camptosaurus, Coelophysis, and many others also emerged during this period.
Marsh tended to be more conservative in his naming, while Cope was more prolific but sometimes hasty, leading to errors and redundancies. Many species named during the Bone Wars were later found to be duplicates or misidentified, a consequence of the rush to publish and claim credit.
The Personal Cost
Both Cope and Marsh paid a high price for their obsession. Their rivalry consumed their personal lives, finances, and reputations. Cope, despite his family wealth, poured so much money into his fossil expeditions that he died nearly penniless in 1897. Marsh, though financially better off due to his uncle's legacy, also exhausted much of his resources and influence by the time of his death in 1899.
Their feud became a public spectacle, culminating in a series of accusations and counteraccusations published in newspapers and scientific journals. Each man tried to discredit the other, sometimes resorting to outright slander. The scientific community was both fascinated and appalled.
A Complicated Legacy
The Bone Wars left a mixed legacy. On one hand, Cope and Marsh laid the groundwork for vertebrate palaeontology in North America. Their fossil collections formed the core of major museum holdings, including the American Museum of Natural History in New York, the Smithsonian Institution in Washington, D.C., and the Peabody Museum at Yale.
Their discoveries captured the public imagination and sparked a wave of interest in dinosaurs that continues to this day. They provided the raw data that later scientists would refine, reclassify, and build upon.
On the other hand, their rivalry set a poor example of scientific conduct. The destruction of fossil sites, the hoarding of specimens, and the rush to publish without proper analysis led to decades of confusion and taxonomic headaches. Many of their mistakes had to be corrected by future generations of palaeontologists.
Lessons from the Bone Wars
The story of Cope and Marsh serves as a cautionary tale. It highlights the dangers of letting personal ambition override scientific integrity. It also shows how even flawed, contentious endeavours can yield valuable results.
Today, palaeontology is a more collaborative and rigorous field, guided by ethical standards and peer review. But the drama of the Bone Wars continues to capture the imagination of scientists and the public alike. Books, documentaries, and even fictional adaptations have drawn from this rich and tumultuous chapter in scientific history.
Conclusion
The Bone Wars were a paradox: a time of extraordinary discovery and equally extraordinary destruction. Cope and Marsh, in their quest to outshine each other, changed the world’s understanding of prehistoric life forever. Their rivalry was messy, personal, and sometimes shameful—but it also laid the foundation for modern dinosaur science.
As we marvel at the towering skeletons in museum halls and read about the latest fossil finds, we owe a strange debt to these two flawed pioneers. The Bone Wars may be over, but their impact lives on in every fossil unearthed and every story told about the ancient giants that once roamed our planet.
Further Reading
Gilded Dinosaur - Mark Jaffe
The Bone Hunters - Url Lanham
The Dinosaur Hunters - Deborah Cadbury
Comments